// Blog / News

Could police compel your customer records?

Share

On November 2 Privacy Commissioner Philippe Dufresne appeared before the Standing Senate Committee on National Security, Defence and Veterans Affairs on Bill C-22, the Lawful Access Act, 2026, which has passed the House and is now in committee study. He described it as an improvement on its predecessor while recommending what he called targeted amendments. One of those amendments is the reason a small business should pay attention.

The amendment that matters to you

Dufresne recommended narrowing the definition of subscriber information to a finite list of discrete identifiers, and restricting the range of persons or entities from whom it may be compelled to telecommunications service providers.

Read the second half carefully. Asking to restrict who can be compelled to telecom providers implies that, as currently drafted, the range is broader than telecom providers. That is the whole point of the recommendation. Whether and how far it extends to ordinary businesses depends on the bill text and on whatever amendments survive, which is exactly why this is a watch item rather than a compliance deadline.

He added that if the government does not narrow the definition, he would recommend adding a carve-out for medical or privileged information from the new production order, and he flagged categories of service carrying a heightened expectation of privacy because of sensitivity: healthcare providers, lawyers, financial institutions and dating apps. If you are in one of those categories, that list is a reasonable proxy for where scrutiny will concentrate.

His other two asks

On the threshold, under the bill police would apply to a judge, establish reasonable grounds to suspect criminal activity, and satisfy the court that subscriber information would assist the investigation. Separately, Dufresne argued the bill lacks an overarching requirement that all obligations be necessary and proportionate, and recommended making that a legal requirement rather than a principle.

And for anyone operating a service: he recommended allowing electronic service providers to trigger a pre-emptive, arm's-length expert assessment where an obligation might create systemic vulnerabilities, pointing to comparable regimes in the UK, Australia and New Zealand. That one responds to industry concern about being ordered to do something that weakens encryption for everybody.

What is and is not settled

Worth stating plainly, because lawful access coverage tends to run ahead of the legislation. The bill has passed the House and is being studied in the Senate. Nothing described here is a current obligation. The Commissioner's recommendations are recommendations, and civil society groups have raised broader objections than his. What you are reading is the regulator telling a committee which parts he thinks are too wide, which is genuinely useful forward intelligence and nothing more.

What a small business should do

  • Nothing urgent, and one cheap thing. Decide now who in your business handles a request from law enforcement, and make sure staff know to take details and promise nothing. That is useful today regardless of C-22, and we have written the practical version of it.
  • Know what identifiers you hold. Subscriber-type information means the account details that connect a person to a service: names, addresses, account numbers, contact details, device or connection identifiers. Most businesses hold more of this than they think.
  • Hold less of it. A retention schedule is the only control that reduces exposure to compelled disclosure, because you cannot be made to produce what you have already deleted for legitimate reasons.
  • If you are in one of the named sensitive categories, healthcare, legal, financial, follow the amendment debate rather than the headlines. A medical or privileged carve-out either appears or it does not, and that distinction will matter to you specifically.
  • Watch for the final text, not the committee coverage. We will cover it if it passes with obligations that reach beyond telecom providers.

The takeaway

Most privacy news for a small business is about protecting data from attackers. This is the other axis: who can lawfully require you to hand it over. The Commissioner has asked the Senate to keep that circle narrow, which tells you the circle is currently wider than he is comfortable with. The sensible response is not alarm, it is knowing what you hold, holding less of it, and deciding in advance who answers the phone.

Sources:Office of the Privacy Commissioner of CanadaCBC News

Do you know which customer identifiers you hold, or who would handle a request for them? We help small businesses answer both and cut what they keep to what they actually need.

Talk to us

Related